Kelly Hartman, MA

Kelly Hartman, MA

President & CEO

Kelly Hartman started out working as direct care staff in a group home in Muncie…truly, because she thought it would look good on her resume. She was delighted (and a bit surprised) to find her niche.

Amy Pickett, MS, LMHC, RBC

Amy Pickett, MS, LMHC, RBC

Vice President & Director of Therapeutic Supports

Amy Pickett graduated from Ball State University in 1991 with a Bachelor’s degree in Psychology. Upon graduating she began pursuing...

Jennifer Lile

Jennifer Lile

Director of Human Resources

Although Jennifer’s initial plan was to be a high school art teacher, life’s turns and twists led to her working...

Libby Malaterre

Libby Malaterre

Director of Finance

Elizabeth ‘Libby’ Malaterre transitioned into her current position as Director of Finance in March 2012, and is excited about the new opportunities this position will bring!

Nina Cribbs

Nina Cribbs

Director of Residential Supports

Nina Cribbs has been working with the Insights Consulting Team since August 2006. Nina has been working with individuals with disabilities since 1987.

Kelly Crawford-Shaw

Kelly Crawford-Shaw

Vice President & Chief Operations Officer (COO)

Kelly Crawford Shaw has been a member of the Insights Consulting team since 2000. Kelly has enjoyed working with people with disabilities and mental illness since high school.

Allen Zhang, MT-BC

Allen Zhang, MT-BC

Music Therapy

Allen Li Zhang is a board-certified music therapist from Appalachian State University and a previous intern at Insights. Driven by...

Alyssa West, MA, LMHC, CSAYC

Alyssa West, MA, LMHC, CSAYC

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Alyssa West graduated from Indiana University Purdue University Indianapolis in 2012 with a Bachelor’s degree in American Sign Language Interpreting, with a minor in Psychology. Alyssa utilized her interpreting skills within medical and mental health settings...

Amanda Davidson

Amanda Davidson

Coordinator of Human Resources

Introduced to her passion for this field 10 years ago, Amanda spent a few years as a Direct Support Staff....

Amy Fistrovich

Amy Fistrovich

Coordinator of Quality Outcomes: Finance

Amy started her career in the Not-for-Profit Sector in 2002.  She worked in the Payroll Area for 16 years. In...

Andrane Jones

Andrane Jones

COORDINATOR OF QUALITY OUTCOMES

Andrane Jones joined Insights Consulting in 2017. She has worked with Individuals with Disabilities for 35 years. 

Andrew Grusak

Andrew Grusak

Front Desk Receptionist

Andrew joined Insights Consulting in April of 2018 as a part-time Direct Support Professional providing respite care for two families....

Angie Sylas, MMT, MT-BC

Angie Sylas, MMT, MT-BC

WellSpring Accredited FCT Trainer Music Therapy, FCT Communication and Body Support, Coordinator of Music Therapy

With nearly 20 years of experience as a Board Certified Music Therapist, Angie has observed the transformation of the disability community with the intentional application of music therapy techniques to support a person-centered approach.

Angela Panyard, MA

Angela Panyard, MA

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Angela graduated from Ball State University with a Bachelor’s degree in Family and Consumer Sciences, and a Master’s degree in Social Psychology. 

Angela Parsons, MT-BC

Angela Parsons, MT-BC

Music Therapy

Angela is excited to join the Insights team! She graduated from Olivet Nazarene University in 2011 with a degree in music education, and recently graduated from IUPUI.

Ann Fienup, MT-BC

Ann Fienup, MT-BC

MUSIC THERAPY

Originally from Iowa, Ann graduated from the University of Iowa, earning her Master’s/Equivalency degree in music therapy. Ann came to Iowa...

Ann Reynolds, MSW, LCSW

Ann Reynolds, MSW, LCSW

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Ann Reynolds-Ward graduated from IUPUI with her Bachelor’s degree and the University of North Carolina with her Master’s degree, both in social work.

Annalyse Ewing, M.Ed.

Annalyse Ewing, M.Ed.

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Annalyse graduated from Purdue University in 2008 with her degree in Law and Society. While working at the Department of...

Antoinette Carter, MT-BC

Antoinette Carter, MT-BC

MUSIC THERAPY

Antoinette is a board-certified music therapist who earned her music therapy degree from Indiana University- Purdue University Fort Wayne (IPFW)...

Anurati Jain, MT-BC

Anurati Jain, MT-BC

MUSIC THERAPY

Anurati is thrilled to join the Insights team! She is a board certified music therapist and a member of the...

Ashley Wagner, MT-BC

Ashley Wagner, MT-BC

MUSIC THERAPY

Ashley Wagner (She/Her) is a Board Certified Music Therapist located on the west side of Indianapolis.  Ashley graduated from the...

Betsy Anton, LMHC

Betsy Anton, LMHC

Mental Health & Wellness

Betsy has worked as a therapist in private practice, outpatient clinics and school-based programs in the greater Indianapolis area since...

Carly Olsen

Carly Olsen

Coordinator of Human Resources - Personnel Data and Compliance

Carly graduated from the University of Utah in 2018 with a BA in Psychology and certificate in Human Factors and...

Camille Bagnola, MT-BC

Camille Bagnola, MT-BC

Camille is thrilled to be joining the Insights community! She is a board-certified music therapist from Canfield, OH. Camille earned...

Carrie Bates

Carrie Bates

Coordinator of Quality Outcomes

Carrie Bates is a Coordinator of Quality Outcomes who helps the individuals we serve ensure the team is meeting their needs.

Cassi Bundy, MS, NCC

Cassi Bundy, MS, NCC

Behavioral Consultant

Cassi graduated from Xavier University in 2007 with a degree in Special Education. Immediately upon graduation, she began teaching at...

Celeste Simpson, MT-BC

Celeste Simpson, MT-BC

MUSIC THERAPY

Celeste is excited to join the team at Insights! Originally from Pittsburgh, PA, she received her bachelor’s in music therapy...

Dana Hayse

Dana Hayse

Coordinator of Mental Health & Wellness

Dana joined us for the opening of Insights Mental Health & Wellness in August 2018.   While serving in an administrative...

David Taylor, LSW

David Taylor, LSW

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Dave is a social worker who has worked with special populations, including children with emotional and behavioral difficulties, adults diagnosed with dementia...

Dessra Spoon, MS, CSAYC

Dessra Spoon, MS, CSAYC

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Dessra has worked in the field of helping others since 1997.  She graduated with her Bachelor’s degree in Psychology in...

Donnie Davidson

Donnie Davidson

Coordinator of Quality Outcomes

Donnie has supported individuals with various intellectual disabilities for the past 13 years in a variety of capacities.

Elaina Cozart, MT-BC

Elaina Cozart, MT-BC

MUSIC THERAPY

Elaina is thrilled to join the Insights team! Originally from Illinois, Elaina earned her Bachelor of Music in Music Therapy...

Ella Brown

Ella Brown

Associate Director of Residential Services
Emily Magary, MT-BC

Emily Magary, MT-BC

MUSIC THERAPY

Emily Magary is thrilled to be a part the Insights team! She is a board-certified music therapist from Evansville, IN....

Erin Shadle, MA

Erin Shadle, MA

Senior Behavioral Consultant, Mental Health & Wellness

Erin Shadle earned her undergraduate degree in Human Development and Social Relationships, with a primary focus in psychology...

Jackie Haines

Jackie Haines

Coordinator of Quality Outcomes

Jackie Haines has been working in the field of disabilities and supporting individuals with developmental disabilities since high school.

Jade Presnell, MS, LSW

Jade Presnell, MS, LSW

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Jade Presnell graduated from Butler University in 2007 with a Bachelor’s Degree in Psychology and English.

Jeff Davies

Jeff Davies

Coordinator of Human Resources: Employee Benefits Specialist

Jeff Davies began his career with Insights Consulting in 2011 working with several residential sites as a Team Leader. In...

Jessie Pelaez, MS

Jessie Pelaez, MS

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Jessie started in the field during college as a direct care professional for individuals with disabilities. She graduated from IU...

Jessica Gundlach, MA

Jessica Gundlach, MA

Behavioral Consultant

Jessica Gundlach graduated from Purdue University in 2016 with a Bachelor of Science degree in Brain and Behavioral Science. Afterwards...

Jordan Cantrell, MA

Jordan Cantrell, MA

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Jordan Thomas graduated from Ball State University in 2012 with a Bachelor’s degree in Psychology and a Master’s degree in Applied Behavior Analysis in 2014.

Julie Cook, MA, RBT

Julie Cook, MA, RBT

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Julie graduated from Ball State University in 2015 with dual Bachelor’s degrees in Psychology and Criminal Justice & Criminology. She...

Kate Rathgeber, MT-BC

Kate Rathgeber, MT-BC

MUSIC THERAPY

Kate is excited to join the Insights Team! She graduated from the University of Dayton with her undergraduate degree in...

Kayce Soros, MT-BC

Kayce Soros, MT-BC

MUSIC THERAPY

Kayce received her bachelor’s degree in music therapy from Slippery Rock University of Pennsylvania and completed her music therapy internship...

Kelly Porten, MT-BC

Kelly Porten, MT-BC

MUSIC THERAPY

Kelly graduated from the College of Wooster in 2014 with a Bachelor’s Degree in Music Therapy. Kelly has experience working...

Kerri Coleman, MA

Kerri Coleman, MA

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Kerri started her career graduating with a Bachelor of Science in Elementary Education from IU and teaching for IPS for 13...

Kevin Carlton, MT-BC

Kevin Carlton, MT-BC

Kevin completed his undergraduate degree in Music Therapy at Shenandoah University in the city of Winchester, Virginia. In July 2020,...

Kristin Mays, LSW

Kristin Mays, LSW

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Kristin Mays, a licensed social worker, joined Insights Consulting...

Kyrie Forrester

Kyrie Forrester

Executive Assistant to the President & CEO

Kyrie joined Insights in November 2019 as the Executive Assistant to Kelly Hartman (President & CEO).  Throughout her life, Kyrie...

Larry Balsley

Larry Balsley

Coordinator of Quality Outcomes - Information Technology

Larry joined Insights in August of 2020 with over twenty years of experience in information systems administration. He enjoys breaking...

Laura Davis, MSW

Laura Davis, MSW

Behavioral Consultant

Laura graduated from the University of Indianapolis with her Masters degree in Social Work. Laura has Bachelors degrees in Psychology...

Leah Reinhart, MT-BC

Leah Reinhart, MT-BC

MUSIC THERAPY

Leah is eager to join the team at Insights Consulting to increase her experience and start off strong as a...

Lena Snapp

Lena Snapp

Coordinator of Quality Outcomes

Lena joined the Insights team in 2014. She has worked in the mental health field in various roles since 1989....

Lisa Foster, MT-BC

Lisa Foster, MT-BC

MUSIC THERAPY

As a certified-Music Therapist, Lisa gained invaluable experience working with individuals on the waiver in the state of Indiana for...

Liz Brown

Liz Brown

Coordinator of Client Resources

Elizabeth ‘Liz’ Brown joined Insights in October 2010 as a direct support professional. In February of 2011, Liz accepted a...

Liz Wrighthouse, M. Ed., RBC

Liz Wrighthouse, M. Ed., RBC

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Liz graduated from Purdue University in 2008 with a degree in Sociology. Immediately upon graduation she began her Master’s program...

Mea May, MT-BC

Mea May, MT-BC

Mea comes to us from the University of Louisville located in Louisville, Kentucky.  She is extremely excited to join our Insights...

Michael Robinson, M.A., M.Ed.

Michael Robinson, M.A., M.Ed.

Behavioral Consultant

Teacher, Coach, Advocate, Leader… these are words that were used to describe Michael Robinson in 20+ years he spent in...

Mike Cary, MA

Mike Cary, MA

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

After graduating from high school, Mike Cary began working in a state operated facility as a psychiatric attendant for two years working with individuals with intellectual disabilities and mental illness.

Mike Massie

Mike Massie

Coordinator of Staff Development

Mike Massie is a graduate of Indiana University where he received his BA degree in Psychology. Mike began providing services to individuals with developmental disabilities in 1988...

Nicholas Stellema

Nicholas Stellema

Senior Coordinator of Quality Outcomes: Residential Compliance and Data Analysis

Nicholas Stellema joined Insights back in June of 2012 as a respite direct support professional (DSP). Prior to that, Nicholas had studied exercise science...

Paige Bailey, MA, LMCH-A

Paige Bailey, MA, LMCH-A

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Paige Bailey graduated in 2011 from Purdue University with a B.A. in Psychology.  She chose to pursue her masters at...

Pamela McCoy, MA, LMHC

Pamela McCoy, MA, LMHC

Behavioral Consultant, Mental Health & Wellness

Pamela received her Master of Arts in Mental Health Counseling in 2014 at Indiana University Purdue University Columbus, and is...

Rachel Kuhn,  MSW

Rachel Kuhn, MSW

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Rachel Kuhn graduated from Ball State University in 1995 with a Bachelor’s degree in Psychology. Upon graduating she began working with dually diagnosed individuals...

Rhonda Adams, MA

Rhonda Adams, MA

Coordinator of Quality Assurance

After 35 years of experience working in the field of developmental disabilities, Rhonda joined Studio OTB in 2011 and the Insights Residential Team in 2013.

Riley Hill, MA

Riley Hill, MA

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Riley joined Insights Consulting in 2013 working as a direct support professional during her college summer breaks. Riley attended Eastern...

Rob Westcott, MS

Rob Westcott, MS

Senior Behavioral Consultant

A lifelong resident of central Indiana, Rob Westcott lives in Bloomington and provides positive behavioral support consultation to individuals with Autism Spectrum Disabilities...

Robert Gross, DMA, MA, MT-BC

Robert Gross, DMA, MA, MT-BC

MUSIC THERAPY

Dr. Robert Gross received his Master of Arts in Music Therapy from Texas Woman’s University and also holds a doctorate...

Ross Robertson, MS, LMHC

Ross Robertson, MS, LMHC

MS -Senior Behavioral Consultant, MENTAL HEALTH & WELLNESS

Ross is a Licensed Mental Health Counselor (LMHC) and behavior consultant specializing in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). He has a clinical focus on mood disorders, trauma/PTSD, behavioral management, managing psychosis, teen/adolescent issues, family systems, and relationship issues. He is a Certified Clinical Trauma Professional (CCTP). He utilizes EMDR (Eye Movement and Desensitization Reprocessing) in addition to several other trauma therapies.

Sandra Jones, MSW, LSW

Sandra Jones, MSW, LSW

Behavioral Consultant

Sandra Jones graduated from Indiana University with a Bachelor’s and Master’s degree in Social Work. Sandy is a Licensed Social Worker.

Sarah McGregor, MA

Sarah McGregor, MA

Senior Behavioral Consultant

After graduating from Indiana University at Bloomington with a Bachelor of Arts in Psychology, Sarah began providing support services to individuals...

Shelie Brummett, MSW, LCSW

Shelie Brummett, MSW, LCSW

Behavioral Consultant

Shelie Brummett graduated from Indiana University in 1994 with a Bachelor’s degree in Psychology. Upon graduating she began her career as an Associate Behavioral Clinician...

Stephanie Burritt, MT-BC

Stephanie Burritt, MT-BC

Music Therapy Intern

Stephanie (she/her) is Insights’ second music therapy intern. She is pursuing her bachelor’s degree in music therapy from Appalachian State...

Stephanie Buttler, MA

Stephanie Buttler, MA

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Stephanie started her career in the field almost 20 years ago as a direct support professional for children with autism...

Taylor Robinson, MT-BC

Taylor Robinson, MT-BC

MUSIC THERAPY

Taylor completed her undergraduate degree in Music Therapy at the University of North Dakota, located in her hometown of Grand...

Todd Nelson

Todd Nelson

Coordinator of Quality Outcomes

Todd T. Nelson joined the Insights Consulting residential team in 2007. He brings with him dedication to improve the lives of people with challenging disabilities...

Vanessa Kinsey

Vanessa Kinsey

Office Manager

Vanessa Kinsey joined Insights in November 2017 as the Receptionist, and transitioned to her current role as Office Manager in...

Vanessa Mashushire, MSW

Vanessa Mashushire, MSW

BEHAVIORAL CONSULTANT

Vanessa obtained her Master of Social Work from the University of Indianapolis. Her concentration was in Mental Health and Addictions....

Vickie Stohl, MT-BC

Vickie Stohl, MT-BC

Music Therapy / Massage Therapist

Vickie has been a Board Certified Music Therapist for five years with a recent training in Neurologic Music Therapy.

Wren Buse, MT-BC

Wren Buse, MT-BC

Music Therapist

Originally from Santa Cruz, California, Wren Buse (they/them) completed their degree in music therapy from University of the Pacific in...